November 14, 2022
3 mins read

UN: India abstains on Ukraine reparations resolution

The support for the resolution was significantly lower than the 143 votes an Assembly resolution received in October condemning Russia’s annexation of Ukrainian territories…writes Arul Louis

Questioning its legality, India has abstained on a UN General Assembly resolution setting up a mechanism for Russian reparations to Ukraine for war damages.

“The legal validity of such a process by a General Assembly Resolution remains unclear,” India’s Permanent Representative Ruchira Kamboj said on Monday after abstaining on the vote.

“We must, therefore, not create mechanisms or set precedents without adequate international legal vetting that have implications for the future functioning of the United Nations and the international economic system,” she said.

Kamboj’s speech also included a criticism of Russia, but without naming it: “The global order that we all subscribe to, is based on international law, the UN Charter and respect for the territorial integrity and sovereignty of all States. These principles must be upheld, without exception.”

The resolution passed with 94 votes, with 14 votes against and 73 abstentions.

It said that Russia “must bear the legal consequences” of its invasion and called for setting up an international registry on the damages caused by Russia’s invasion of Ukraine and for creating a mechanism for reparation.

The support for the resolution was significantly lower than the 143 votes an Assembly resolution received in October condemning Russia’s annexation of Ukrainian territories.

This was because several countries expressed reservations similar to India’s on legal grounds.

The Caricom group of 15 Caribbean countries, for example abstained on this resolution but had voted for the last one in the Assembly, as had others like Saudi Arabia.

The voting also reflected a deepening polarisation in the 193-member UN on Ukraine once the topic of reparations was introduced.

Bahamas Permanent Representative Stan Smith, who spoke on behalf of the Caricom, said that colonisers and exploiters also have “moral and legal responsibility for past actions” like colonialism and slavery.

Some nations like Sierra Leone said that the resolution reeked of double standards because countries proposing reparations for Ukraine had opposed reparations for colonialism and slavery.

Kamboj said that it was “unfortunate that as the trajectory of the Ukrainian conflict unfolds, the entire global South has suffered a substantial collateral damage”.

The zooming prices of petroleum and fertilisers and the shortage of food grains have hit developing countries the hardest.

“It is thus critical that the voice of the global south be heard, and their legitimate concerns be duly addressed,” she said.

Kamboj said that with a “people-centric” outlook, India was providing humanitarian assistance to Ukraine and economic assistance to neighbours reeling from the escalating costs of food and fertilisers.

Any steps that would hinder dialogue to end the war should be avoided, she said.

“We need to objectively consider whether a reparation process through a vote in the General Assembly would contribute to efforts at a resolution of the conflict,” she added.

The UN Security Council, which under the UN Charter has the teeth to act, has been crippled by permanent member Russia’s veto, propelling the Western countries to take up Ukrainian matters in the Assembly, which does not have enforcement powers but can make a moral point.

US Deputy Permanent Representative Richard Mills called the resolution “a critical step toward accountability”.

“It highlights the importance of gathering evidence to support eventual claims for compensation from Russia on a non-criminal track for the injuries, the deaths, and the extensive damage to public and private property caused by Russia’s internationally wrongful acts in Ukraine,” he said.

Russia’s Permanent Vasily Nebenzia accused the western countries of wanting to use the resolution as a pretext to seize Moscow’s frozen assets.

ALSO READ: Sunak heads to G20 with veiled attack on China

Previous Story

Sharia law punishments return to Afghanistan

Next Story

Taiwan, Xinjiang and Hong Kong dominate Biden-Xi meet

Latest from -Top News

US-India ties is a slow-motion catastrophe

For the first time in two decades, Trump’s actions, statements, and coercive tone have made relations with the US a combustible domestic political issue in India, writes Manoj Menon The post-globalisation uncertainty

Modi Welcomes Marcos Jr to Delhi

PM Modi Welcomes Philippines President Marcos Jr to Strengthen India-Philippines Ties…reports Asian Lite News Prime Minister Narendra Modi on Tuesday warmly welcomed Philippines President Ferdinand R. Marcos Jr at Hyderabad House in

Is Bangladesh Turning Into a Theocratic State?

The rise of radical Islamic influence under Yunus’s watch threatens to transform Bangladesh from a secular democracy into a theocratic state….writes Anna Mahjar-Barducci Nobel Peace Prize laureate Muhammad Yunus’s transition from economist

Post-370 Kashmir Reinvents Itself

The developments suggest that Kashmir’s post-abrogation journey is not merely political – it is profoundly social, economic, and cultural….writes Shashikant Trivedi Six years after the abrogation of Article 370, Jammu and Kashmir

Munir’s Soft Coup in Uniform

From Beijing to Washington, Asim Munir has emerged as Pakistan’s most visible face on the international stage….reports Asian Lite News As Pakistan’s powerful Army Chief, Field Marshal Asim Munir, concluded yet another
Go toTop

Don't Miss

BJP is scared of INDIA bloc, says AAP leader

The partners in the INDIA bloc, Congress and the AAP,

Govt has no plans for divestment of BSNL

“There is no plan under consideration for disinvestment of BSNL,”