August 10, 2022
2 mins read

Economic impact assessment of freebies essential, SC told

The submissions have been made in a PIL filed by Upadhyay seeking action against political parties for “irrational freebies”…reports Asian Lite News

The petitioner against the ‘freebies’ promises during polls has told the Supreme Court that the country’s two highest economic bodies have expressed concern on their distribution by the state government and emphasised that before distribution and/or promise of freebies, an “economic impact assessment” is essential for a sustainable economy.

Senior advocate Vijay Hansaria, on behalf of the petitioner, advocate Ashwini Upadhyay, said: “It is submitted that two highest economic bodies of the country have expressed concern and long-term impact on the distribution of freebies by the states without proper fiscal and budgetary management. It is submitted that before distribution and/or promise of freebies, an ‘Economic Impact Assessment’ is essential for a sustainable economy.”

The submissions have been made in a PIL filed by Upadhyay seeking action against political parties for “irrational freebies”.

Hansaria contended that under Article 293(3) of the Constitution, the state government cannot raise any loan or borrow money where the loan of the Union government is outstanding, and in such circumstances, borrowing can be made only with the consent of the Centre and it can impose such conditions as it thinks fit under clause (4).

“It is submitted that the state governments have been borrowing money even when the loan from Government of India is outstanding without complying with the requirements of Article 293(3) and (4). It is necessary to have a strict enforcement of these provisions including a ‘system of credit rating’ being introduced for grant of credit facilities to the state government”, said the submissions, filed through advocate Ashwani Kumar Dubey.

The petitioner urged the top court to constitute a Committee of Experts to make recommendations after examining the practice of making electoral commitments involving financial resources (freebies) without adequacy of budgetary provisions and suggest remedial measures, formulation of a comprehensive policy to reduce debt to GSDP (Gross State Domestic Product) ratio of the states, formulate principles of debt sustainability and fiscal discipline of the state government, and prepare an ‘Economic Impact Assessment’ module to be published an before any freebies are announced or distributed by the state government/ political parties etc.,

On August 3, the Supreme Court, while hearing Upadhyay’s PIL, had acknowledged that some help to the poor is required, but it also wanted to know the impact of freebies on the national economy. The top court had sought suggestions from stakeholders and recommended setting up an expert panel to scrutinise the issues associated with “irrational freebies”.

The top court asked stakeholders like the Centre, the NITI Aayog, the Finance Commission and the Reserve Bank of India, to brainstorm on the issues associated with freebies announcement during polls.

ALSO READ: India-Pak backchannel talks hit impasse

Previous Story

‘Part of our culture’: Court rejects plea seeking ban on kite flying

Next Story

India fintech market set to reach $1tn in AUM

Latest from India News

Rahul, the court, and the patriotism trap

When judges slip into moral commentary, especially on loyalty to the nation, they risk blurring the line between verdict and ideology, writes Aravind Rajeev A rare moment of judicial overreach shook the

Doval in Moscow Amid US Tariff Threat

During his Moscow visit, NSA Doval will discuss defence ties, the oil issue, and the upcoming Modi-Putin summit..reports Asian Lite news India’s National Security Advisor Ajit Doval is set to meet senior

After Pakistan, China Backing Iran Too?

China and Iran signed a 25-year comprehensive cooperation agreement that covered trade, energy and security, showcasing the strategic value that Beijing places on Tehran….reports Asian Lite News Despite its long-standing claims of

US-India ties is a slow-motion catastrophe

For the first time in two decades, Trump’s actions, statements, and coercive tone have made relations with the US a combustible domestic political issue in India, writes Manoj Menon The post-globalisation uncertainty

Modi Welcomes Marcos Jr to Delhi

PM Modi Welcomes Philippines President Marcos Jr to Strengthen India-Philippines Ties…reports Asian Lite News Prime Minister Narendra Modi on Tuesday warmly welcomed Philippines President Ferdinand R. Marcos Jr at Hyderabad House in
Go toTop

Don't Miss

India records 1,68,063 cases, 277 deaths

Maharashtra recorded the maximum number of 1,247 cases followed by

How India-South Africa is taking on Big Pharma at WTO

India and South Africa have the backing of a large