August 5, 2022
2 mins read

CAG report flags irregularity by NHAI

CAG in the report also said that NHAI failed to levy penalty upon the Concessionaires applying for such renegotiation…reports Asian Lite News

In its compliance audit report on ‘Rationalisation/Deferment of Premium in BOT Projects in NHAI’, the CAG noted that the National Highways Authority of India (NHAI) extended undue benefit to concessionaires.

National Highways were being developed under different mode of execution including Built Operate & Transfer (BOT) (Toll), Built Operate & Transfer (BOT) (Annuity) and Engineering, Procurement & Construction (EPC) Mode.

“NHAI extended undue benefit to concessionaires by resorting to post-tender amendments. The premium payable by the concessionaire was laid down in a legal contract drawn up after an open bidding process, in which premium offered was the one and only parameter in deciding upon the financial bids (request for proposal). Any post tender/ contract amendment tantamounts to vitiating the entire tendering process, against the principle of sanctity of contracts and unfair with respect to other bidders,” said the report which was tabled in the Parliament on Thursday.

The CAG report noted that the scheme was formulated on the basis of flawed presumptions. While proposing the Cabinet note, a list of 23 projects, which were awarded on premium but whose Appointed Date was yet to be declared, was annexed and the status of languishing projects, along with need for policy for revival of these projects, was highlighted in the background of the Cabinet Note. Finally, Option C which proposed rescheduling of premium in respect of all stressed projects was approved.

“However, none of these listed projects availed the scheme. Out of the 23 projects, which formed the basis for inception of this policy, 18 projects could not take off and were subsequently terminated/ foreclosed while the remaining five projects, though started, were not completed till December 2019,” said the report.

The CAG report noted that the policy or scheme for rationalisation of premium was neither considered nor approved in the NHAI Board Meeting and MoRTH (ministry of road transport and highways) failed to adhere to guidelines of the Cabinet Secretariat for circulation/approval of Cabinet Notes

“There were huge variations in total project cost of NHAI vis-a-vis Concessionaire’s total project cost resulting in high debt servicing. The direct implication of this higher debt servicing is on the subsistence revenue of Concessionaire, which in turn had direct relation with premium deferred,” said the report.

CAG in the report also said that NHAI failed to levy penalty upon the Concessionaires applying for such renegotiation.

“This was to compensate for the special benefit that was being provided to the Concessionaires beyond the signed agreement. In a way, this was to mitigate the moral hazard of reopening a signed agreement to bail out the sector. This resulted in loss of Rs 51.01 crore to NHAI and undue favour to the concessionaires,” said the report.

ALSO READ: Will Bajwa or his successor reconcile ties with India?
Previous Story

Court’s duty to separate grain from chaff: SC

Next Story

Must travel Swiss

Latest from India News

India Skips UNGA Vote, Flags LeT, JeM Threat

India Urges Global Action to Prevent Terror Groups from Exploiting Afghanistan…reports Asian Lite News While abstaining from a UN General Assembly resolution on Afghanistan, India has urged the international community to ensure

BRICS Under India to Prioritise Climate, Health

Modi Sets Vision for India’s 2026 BRICS Presidency, Promising a ‘Humanity-First’ Agenda Focused on Climate Action and Global Health…reports Asian Lite News At the Rio 2025 BRICS Summit, Prime Minister Narendra Modi

Trump: Big India Deal Coming Soon

Trump Says US ‘Close to Deal with India’ Amid Fresh Global Tariffs…reports Asian Lite News In a major development on the global trade front, US President Donald Trump has announced that the

Modi’s Grand Brazil Entry

Modi Gets Grand Welcome in Brazil with Fusion of Shiva Tandava and Samba Rhythms…reports Asian Lite News Prime Minister Narendra Modi was accorded a rousing reception in Brasilia as he arrived for

BRICS Endorses India’s Stand on Terror

The treaty proposed by India within the UN framework aims to provide a comprehensive legal basis for combating terrorism….reports Asian Lite News The leaders’ joint statement, issued after the 17th BRICS summit
Go toTop

Don't Miss

AustraHind: India, Australia hold joint military drill in Pune 

This two-week training program is designed to enhance cooperation and

Govt to develop portal for employment seeking senior citizens

The aim is to devise ways to ensure senior citizens