September 8, 2021
3 mins read

Writing judgments involve skillful application of law, logic: SC

A bench of Justices D.Y. Chandrachud and M.R. Shah said: “Writing judgments is an art, though it involves skillful application of law and logic….reports Asian Lite News

The Supreme Court, while setting aside a high court order granting bail to murder accused, on Tuesday held that writing judgments is “an art”, and quality can never be sacrificed for quantity.

A bench of Justices D.Y. Chandrachud and M.R. Shah said: “Writing judgments is an art, though it involves skillful application of law and logic. We are conscious of the fact that the judges may be overburdened with pending cases and the arrears, but at the same time, quality can never be sacrificed for quantity.”

It noted that a judgment should be coherent, systematic, and logically organised, and enable the reader to trace the fact to a logical conclusion on the basis of legal principles. “The judicial opinion is to be written in such a way that it elucidates in a convincing manner and proves the fact that the verdict is righteous and judicious. What the court says, and how it says it, is equally important as what the court decides.”

The bench pointed out that it has across many judgments which lack clarity on facts, reasoning, and the findings. “Many times, it is very difficult to appreciate what the learned judge wants to convey through the judgment and because of that, matters are required to be remanded for fresh consideration,” it noted.

The top court added that the term “judgment” is loosely used as judicial opinion or decision, and added it is pertinent to examine the important elements in a judgment in order to fully understand the art of reading a judgment.

Ramana
At a ceremony held today (April 24, 2021) at 1100 hrs in the Ashoka Hall, Rashtrapati Bhavan, Shri Justice Nuthalapati Venkata Ramana, was sworn in as the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court of India. He made and subscribed to the oath of office before the President.

The top court made these observations while delivering a judgment on an appeal filed by UP resident Shakuntala Shukla, a widow of the deceased, against the Allahabad High Court order granting bail to four accused in a murder case.

The bench noted that “unless judgment is not in a precise manner, it would not have a sweeping impact. There are some judgments that eventually get overruled because of lack of clarity”.

It said there must be a clarity on the final relief granted and a party to the litigation must know what actually he or she got by way of final relief. “It is desirable that the judgment should have a clarity, both on facts and law and on submissions, findings, reasonings and the ultimate relief granted,” added the bench.

It said the high court did not consider the seriousness of the offence and the gravity of the accusation against the accused and their antecedents and conduct by giving threats to the witnesses during trial and even thereafter. “The High Court has committed a grave error in releasing the accused on bail pending appeals against the judgment and order of conviction for the offences under Sections 302/149, 201 r/w 120B IPC,” it said.

ALSO READ: Field formations of Indian armed forces get greater financial powers

Previous Story

Field formations of Indian armed forces get greater financial powers

Next Story

Citizens extend support to Javed Akhtar, Naseeruddin Shah

Latest from -Top News

Pak, Iran Crack Down on Afghan Refugees

Most of those affected are in Islamabad and Rawalpindi, where authorities have intensified pressure on Afghan nationals to leave….reports Asian Lite News As forced deportation and illegal detention of Afghan refugees continues,

Balochistan Bleeds Under Pakistan’s Iron Fist

The Baloch people have long faced marginalization and exploitation. Enforced disappearances, extrajudicial killings, and collective punishment have further alienated the Baloch population…reports Deepak Kumar The scale and the audacity of the attack

Luxon’s India Visit Kicks Off Today

Prime Minister Luxon will be accompanied by a high-level delegation, including senior officials, ministers, business leaders…reports Asian Lite News New Zealand Prime Minister Christopher Luxon is scheduled to arrive in India on

Pakistan Blames Kabul for Jaffar Express Attack

The Pakistan Foreign Office spokesperson Shafqat Ali Khan has stated that the intercepted calls confirmed links between the attackers and Afghanistan…reports Asian Lite News Pakistan continues to accuse Afghanistan of orchestrating the
Go toTop

Don't Miss

Omar challenges Azad to contest polls against him

Abdullah expressed his disappointment with Azad, accusing him of resorting

ICMR rules out 4th Covid wave in India

Speaking to Avinash Prbhakar, ICMR additional director general Samiran Panda