August 13, 2021
2 mins read

Mere identification in test parade not substantive basis for conviction: SC

It observed that a TIP under Section 9 of the Evidence Act is not substantive evidence in a criminal prosecution but is only corroborative evidence…reports Asian Lite News

The Supreme Court said mere identification of an accused in the test identification parade (TIP) cannot form the substantive basis for conviction and there cannot be repeated TIPs till such time that the prosecution is successful in obtaining identification of the accused.

A bench of Justices Navin Sinha and R. Subhash Reddy said: “We find it extremely disturbing that both the trial court and the high court did not go into this aspect at all to satisfy themselves if any TIP had been proved to have been held at all and that too in accordance with the law.”

It observed that a TIP under Section 9 of the Evidence Act is not substantive evidence in a criminal prosecution but is only corroborative evidence. “The purpose of holding a TIP during the stage of investigation is only to ensure that the investigating agency prima facie was proceeding in the right direction where the accused may be unknown or there was a fleeting glance of the accused,” it added.

“Mere identification in the test identification parade therefore cannot form the substantive basis for conviction unless there are other facts and circumstances corroborating the identification,” it held.

The finding by the top court came while acquitting two persons from dacoity charges on the ground that repeated TIPs were conducted to identify them.

The bench said it regrets to note that even the original seizure memo was not produced by the prosecution which speaks volumes about the nature of investigation done by the police.

It noted that it cannot help but notice the very casual manner in which the police conducted the investigation by TIP supported by a claim of recovery to link the two events but failed miserably to establish either.

“On the same set of evidence, two of the accused, one of whom was also identified in the 4th round and in the 2nd round while the other was never identified have been acquitted in separate trials. Prosecution witness 2 turned hostile in that trial denying identification of the accused, and also of the recovered goods,” the bench added.

“In the facts and circumstances of the case, we are unable to uphold the conviction of the appellants. The appeals are allowed, and the appellants are directed to be released forthwith unless wanted in any other case,” it said.

ALSO READ: India and Australia likely to hold maiden two plus two meeting next month

Previous Story

Right to shelter doesn’t mean govt housing for unlimited period: SC

Next Story

22 Bills passed in Monsoon Session: Govt

Latest from India News

Another Taliban Envoy Posted in India

These back-to-back appointments in Mumbai and Hyderabad signal Kabul’s intent to maintain cordial diplomatic relations with New Delhi….reports Asian Lite News After Mumbai, another Afghan Taliban representative has taken charge of the

Rahul, the court, and the patriotism trap

When judges slip into moral commentary, especially on loyalty to the nation, they risk blurring the line between verdict and ideology, writes Aravind Rajeev A rare moment of judicial overreach shook the

Doval in Moscow Amid US Tariff Threat

During his Moscow visit, NSA Doval will discuss defence ties, the oil issue, and the upcoming Modi-Putin summit..reports Asian Lite news India’s National Security Advisor Ajit Doval is set to meet senior

After Pakistan, China Backing Iran Too?

China and Iran signed a 25-year comprehensive cooperation agreement that covered trade, energy and security, showcasing the strategic value that Beijing places on Tehran….reports Asian Lite News Despite its long-standing claims of

US-India ties is a slow-motion catastrophe

For the first time in two decades, Trump’s actions, statements, and coercive tone have made relations with the US a combustible domestic political issue in India, writes Manoj Menon The post-globalisation uncertainty
Go toTop

Don't Miss

NSA Doval meets Iranian counterpart in Tehran

The two officials discussed economic, political and security issues concerning

UP: BJP ahead in 248 seats, SP in 112

The Congress and Bahujan Samaj Party (BSP) were leading in